Friday, February 27, 2009
A Film and Novel Comparison of Amy Tan's "The Joy Luck Club"
I did a comparison review between the novel by Amy Tan, “The Joy Luck Club” and the movie. I found that although the general story line was still intact throughout the movie much of the fine details in the novel were deleted from the story line. These details in the novel were important in understanding the meaning of the situation and relayed more of the emotions surrounding it. The story conveys the ideals and struggles of four Chinese born mothers and their Chinese-American daughters. The idea that the mothers felt their daughters were in someway ashamed by them and the struggles of their daughters to prove their worth to the mothers was evident throughout the story. In the story the mothers adhered to the Chinese culture and the meanings behind the actions, however the daughters rebelled against their culture growing up. Nonetheless, as adults the four daughters began to appreciate the true meaning behind the traditions their mothers taught them. This story is one of tragedy and struggles endured by the mothers and as well, in not to the same degree, by the daughters. Ultimately the ending of the story conveyed the message of acceptance; acceptance of who we are and our culture.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment